2 replies [Last post]
Anonymous
's picture
How does Caring School Community compare to Responsive Classroom

I am new to a district that is using the "Caring School Community Program". I was wondering how close to the Responsive Classroom approach is this program? Are their philosophies the same. I am not seeing a "way of being" present in the CSC program...are we missing something? I do a morning meeting every day and have established a community in my classroom. I am having a difficult time "building community" in the school since everyone seems to be on different pages. Please advise!!! Thank you!

Jeni Frazee (not verified)
Jeni Frazee's picture

Hello -- what an excellent question!  I don't really have any aswer, but I am wondering the same thing.  I'm watching a webinar I am a true  RC fan, and as part of a Master's program -- it's at:

http://www.edutopia.org/social-emotional-learning-nclb-webinar

and the superintendent speaking about this program sounds like he's talking about RC ... even some of his words are exact quotes from RC stated guided principles, like "The social curriculum is as important as the academic curriculum," and the strucutures are the same, as far as I can tell.

Wondering about the level of support that your administrators are giving in implementing this innovation -- which sounds really wonderful -- in developing a common vision among staff and the professional development, community building, and recognition that would support the full implementation of this change? 

Thank you for sharing your experience by asking this question -- Have you gotten any (more helpful) replies, or more insights into this? - I'm really interested in whether SEL programs work, and what factors make them work or not --

It sounds like you are familiar with RC, and very committed to giving your best to your students, and to your school community  -- I wish you the best in your journey -

Best,

Jeni Frazee

Grade 3 Teacher

Central Maine

Ginger Cook's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/15/2009

 

Thanks so much for your question!  And sorry for the slow response!  We at DSC are big fans of Responsive Classroom (RC) and find it to be one of the most philosophically aligned approaches to what we do.  We often reference RC ourselves (you’d see all the books on my shelves) and work with many schools that use both approaches.  CSC's Class Meetings are actually mentioned in the NEFC Morning Meetings book. Caring School Community holds many of the same core principles that you are familiar with in Responsive Classroom, such as:

  • Creating respectful, caring places to learn
  • Developing and practicing social skills
  • Ensuring that schools create the foundation of social skills and safety for all students
  • Meeting students basic needs for autonomy, belonging, and competence
  • Helping us know our students and their families more fully

CSC and RC have common goals of attending to students’ social and academic growth simultaneously. CSC and RC compliment each other in many ways. After spending a week at the Responsive Classroom institute a few summers ago, I spent some time thinking about how these two programs can support each other.  CSC provides explicit tools and lesson plans.  RC helps extend this language throughout the school day. RC provides team builders and daily routines to build relationships and a sense of fun.  CSC structures class meetings to solve problems, reflect, and make decisions as a class. RC helps teachers think about how to organize the classroom and choices throughout the day to support students. CSC takes community building beyond the classroom to cross-age relationships and family involvement.

Why might teachers use both programs? CSC provides some explicit, concrete lessons for teachers to facilitate.  We’ve spent a lot of time thinking about how to build empathy and understanding, construct open-ended questions, use cooperative structures, and increase authentic student voice.  We’ve also thought about how to support this sense of connectedness and belonging outside the classroom and cross-grade and with families and the larger community. Many teachers have found this a nice compliment to what RC provides – a daily morning meeting structure, ways to think through classroom procedures and discipline that are still caring and developmentally appropriate, and ways to continue to build relationships.

One teacher I know in Florida who uses both programs shared this experience with me: “ I infuse Caring Schools Community (CSC) within the Responsive Classroom (RC) approach as they are both founded on similar guiding principals. Each supports the other, and therefore offers me, the teacher, tremendous support in fostering the academic, social, and ethical goals I have for my students.  I use Morning Meeting daily to build a safe community of learners, friends, and thinkers, which later on serves as a very supportive structure to hold our CSC class meetings. The RC approach focuses the power of teacher language and CSC offers useful prompts to help scaffold my own development in this area. The Cross-Age Buddy Activities are such a useful tool to extend the sense of belonging, significance, and fun outside the walls of our classroom and into a part of the larger school community. I often use the Homeside Activities to bridge the gap and to build that Home-School connection. Students LOVE bringing part of our school family into their own homes!”

Please let me know if you have other questions and how we can help you as you dig into CSC.   I hear your pain of trying to develop community when teachers aren’t on the same page.   We’ll soon have a new “Resources for Implementation page” that might be useful to you.  The red Teacher’s Calendar also helps provide the bigger picture of what Class Meetings are trying to accomplish and some of the facilitation techniques that can have great impact beyond the meetings when used throughout the school day.

Good luck with the rest of your year and thanks again for your question!

Ginger

 

Post Reply

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly. If you have a Gravatar account associated with the e-mail address you provide, it will be used to display your avatar.